Sourdough Pie Crust
Sourdough Pie Crust, where have you been all my life? This pie crust is tender, flaky and tastes amazing. This just might become your go-to pie crust recipe. This recipe uses an entire cup of sourdough discard.
If you’re a sourdough-bread baker, you know how painful it is to throw away a whole cup of hard-earned yeasty goodness every time you need to replenish your starter. This recipe is a great way to use that discard to make an incredible pie crust.
If you don’t already have one, I can show you how to make a sourdough starter and how to feed a sourdough starter.
Why Sourdough Pie Crust is so good:
- Sourdough discard does amazing things for the flavor and texture of a basic flaky pie dough.
- Sourdough starter is acidic. Acidic ingredients tenderize gluten. Sourdough discard helps keep this pie crust tender.
- As the crust bakes there is a tiny bit of lift from the natural yeast in the sourdough starter. I find that lift helps make the crust even flakier as the air pockets in the dough poof up a bit and separate the layers of dough.
- Sourdough Pie Crust smells amazing as it’s baking in the oven. The yeasty, bready smell is totally tempting.
Ingredients
Ingredient Notes
- Flour – This recipe uses a mixture of all purpose and cake flour. All purpose flour will give the dough enough structure so it can hold the flaky texture and a small proportion of cake flour will help keep it tender. In a pinch, you can use bleached AP flour and get good results.
- Fat – I like to use a mixture of half vegetable shortening and half butter. The vegetable shortening has a higher melting point and keeps the crust from slumping as it bakes. The butter is, well, delicious! You can use all vegetable shortening for a vegan pie crust or all butter if that’s your preference. I sometimes use leaf lard in my pie crust. If you have that available you can use it in place of the shortening.
- Sourdough Discard – This recipe was developed using a 100% hydration starter. That means the starter is fed with equal weights of starter, flour and water. You may need to adjust the amount of starter in the recipe based on the moisture level of your starter.
How to make Sourdough Pie Crust
See the recipe card for detailed measurements and instructions.
- Mix the fat in two stages.
- First mix in the shortening, then toss in the slices of cold butter.
- Add the sourdough discard to the flour/butter mixture.
- There is no other water in the crust other than the water in the starter.
- Mix with a spatula until the dough starts to come together.
- Use your hands to gather the dough together until the all the loose flour is mixed in.
- Gather the dough into a “shaggy” mass.
- Do not knead, just gently gather the dough together.
- Wrap the dough and refrigerate for several hours or over night before rolling.
- This will give the flour time to absorb the water in the dough.
- The bits of butter and a little lift from the starter will help form the flakes.
I used Sourdough Pie Crust to make a sensational Vanilla Pear Pie and the best Chicken Pot Pie ever.
I know you hate to throw away that sourdough discard. Check out these recipes that use sourdough discard.
If you love this recipe as much as I do, I’d really appreciate a star rating and a quick comment. Ratings and comments help my recipes show in search results. Thanks!
Sourdough Pie Crust
Ingredients
- 7 ½ oz all purpose flour (1 ½ cups (see note))
- 3 ½ oz cake flour (⅔ cup)
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1 tablespoon granulated sugar
- 4 oz vegetable shortening (or leaf lard, cold)
- 4 oz unsalted butter (very cold and sliced into ¼" thin slices)
- 8 oz sourdough discard (1 cup (100% hydration))
Instructions
- Combine 7 ½ oz all purpose flour, 3 ½ oz cake flour, 1 teaspoon salt and 1 tablespoon granulated sugar. Whisk together to mix the ingredients evenly.
- Using your fingers, cut 4 oz lard or shortening into the flour mixture until it resembles coarse corn meal. Using your fingers, toss 4 oz unsalted butter into the flour mixture. Allow the slices of butter to break up into slightly smaller pieces into the flour. Work quickly so the butter doesn't get warm. Don't break the butter down completely. There should be some large flakes remaining.
- Pour 8 oz sourdough discard onto the flour all at once and toss to combine. Gently press the dough just until it comes together. It will look a little dry in spots. The moisture will redistribute in the dough as it rests.
- Wrap the dough and refrigerate for at least 2-3 hours before using.
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
I was looking for a pie crust recipe using corn meal and ran across yours. Poking a little farther I ran across your recipe for sourdough pie crust. I decided to try combining them. I substituted the cake flour with blue corn meal I ground in my grain mill. I replaced the sugar with honey and added a teaspoon of cider vinegar. After mixing the dough I did a frisagge to bring the dough together.
I rolled it out and used it for a turkey pot pie. The flavor and texture were terrific. My wife loved the flavor.
I have always wanted to try leaf lard. Is there a supplier/brand you recommend? I tried using super market lard once but wound up throwing it and the pie away. It was awful!
Looking forward to trying some of your other recipes. Thanks for sharing!
I get my leaf lard from a friend. Her cousin is a butcher. If you have any real butcher shops in your area check with them. You can stock up. It freezes very well.
Thank you for this wonderful recipe! It a go to in my life. I always have some on hand in the fridge, which makes throwing together a quiche, pot pie, or fruit tart a breeze!
Thanks, Bethany. I always have some in my freezer too. It’s quick to put together when you need to feed your starter.
Is this a double or single recipe?
Double.
Does this make enough dough for a two crust pie or only a single crust?
Double.
Yum! Loved the texture and tasted perfect!
I’m SO EXCITED about this!! The kids picked 80000 apples this past weekend that are calling out to be made into your maple apple pie. One question, I see another commenter mentioned whole wheat absorbing more water. My starter is 100% hydration whole wheat…does that effect anything when using AP and cake flour in the recipe? The sourdough world is new to me !
So you’ll be using a whole wheat flour discard to make this crust? That shouldn’t be a problem. I make a whole wheat pie crust and it has a nice texture. If the dough seems dry after you add the discard just sprinkle a little more water over the dough while mixing it together.
Hi, I’m making this for my pumpkin pie. Do I need to prebake the pie crust?
For pumpkin pie I would blind bake the crust so it doesn’t end up soggy.
Any suggestions for doing this with a wheat-free discard? My daughter loves pies and I’ve made her a wheat-free starter but it’s a lot thicker than the normal one even though I do the same ratio of ingredients. I made this recipe over the summer with the regular discard and it was so good, I wanted to use it for pumpkin pie this week, but I feel bad not letting her eat the crust (it’s my favorite part!)
Thanks!
Hi Kim, sorry I don’t have experience with wheat free recipes. Maybe someone else can make a suggestion? Would the entire recipe have to be wheat free?
@Eileen Gray, yeah, it does. It’s not gluten that’s the problem (common mix-up, you can actually have one without the other!)
About to give it a try! We’ll see how it goes. She usually eats most things without complaining, so that’s good.
It was extra crumbly so I added more water (not sure how much, a few splashes until it seemed good). I did have to mix it more though because I didn’t realize how crumbly until after I took it out of the fridge. And I had run out of shortening which is hard to get here (in the UK) so used more butter. Daughter had a taste as I was transferring her mini pies to another container and she said it was good, so it probably turned out fine. In future, I will just add some more water at the start.
Thanks again!
Hello! I’m a huge sourdough starter fan and am so happy I found your website! One of my cookbooks is a book all about bacon and one of the recipes in the cookbook calls to use clarified bacon fat to make a pie crust. I’d love to make a pie crust using both sourdough starter and bacon grease! In your opinion, do you believe replacing the vegetable shortening for clarified bacon fat (cold) could work?
Yes. I almost always use leaf lard instead of vegetable shortening when I make pie dough.
I’m ‘babysitting’ the sourdough starter from work and need some discard recipes to try.
This looks simple and delicious.
Is it possible to make without the shortening, just substitute more butter?
Thanks!
Yes!
Looks good and I’m about to try your recipe. But why perpetuate the myth that you need to discard starter? Sure there’s a period in the beginning when it makes sense not to feed the whole developing starter, but after that, there’s no reason to throw any starter away. Just keep the amounts small and then there’s no waste. Make more if you want unfed starter.
There are a million ways to make and keep starter. For those who prefer not have less discard I recommend keeping a small starter.
Update: this was easily the absolute best pie crust I have ever made both taste-wise and because of flakiness. Thanks for the recipe!
This recipe sounds great! I’m making a Savoury pie do i newsroom add the sugar or could I reduce the amount of sugar?
The sugar doesn’t make the crust sweet, just helps with tenderizing and browning. I always use the sugar even for savory pies.
Am I overlooking the directions for baking this crust? I don’t see a recommended time or temperature. My recipe uses a store bought crust.
I don’t include baking directions here because the time and temperature will be specific to the recipe you are making. Use the time and temperature listed in the recipe, even if it uses store bought crust. The time will be shorter is you’re using an aluminum pie plate and longer if you’re using ceramic or glass. What type of pie are you making?
Hi Eileen. Thanks for the recipe. I made a rhubarb pie this afternoon that we plan on having for dinner and it smells heavenly. I followed the recipe closely and wound up with a very dry dough that was difficult to roll out. So, I’ve come back to reread your directions. Just a note to anyone else trying this: pay attention to the hydration of your starter. I needed more water, which I should have added but didn’t because I failed to take my starter hydration into account (it’s 100%). I’ll know next time. Thanks again.
@Robin, She says her starter is 100% so I suspect that it depends on the type of flour in the starter, eg whole wheat will absorb more compared to AP so you will have a thicker starter if using WW.
Great idea. Thanks for the details.
I have started refrigerating my starter for 1/2 week so I don’t have to feed it daily. I am wondering though of any recommendations for freezing the pie crust dough and how long it could keep that way.
Sorry for the delayed response, I was on vacation. I freeze unbaked pie dough all the time. Wrapped tightly, it will last several months in the freezer.
I am excited to try this recipe. One question though. The only discard I have right now has been in the refrigerator fof s while and has Hooch on top of it. I usually mix the hooch in. Do you think I could use that or would it be too acidic? My discard has been in the refrigerator for weeks.
The discard is really just used as the liquid (and some flour) in this recipe. So the ripe starter would work fine unless it has an unpleasant or “off” smell/flavor. Mix in the hooch and if it smells pleasant enough then go ahead and use it.
Hi! The longer I ferment my dough, the better Im able to digest wheat. I’m somewhat gluten intolerant. Could I use fed starter then let the mixed recipe sit out for awhile before the refrigerator process? Or would the unfed starter be used as per recipe and mixed recipe sit out before refrigeration. Do you think I would have the same benefit with unfed?
I can’t speak to the health benefits. But I would say the best option would be to mix the dough with the discard then leave the dough in the refrigerator for a day or two before using. Just like any other pie dough, you do want to keep the fat cold so you don’t loose the flakes.
Hi! How long should the pie crust cook in the oven and on what temperature?
It depends on how you’re using it. Bake it according to the directions of the pie you are making.
I’m also curious about the bake time, i want to make a cranberry curd pie and don’t want to overbake it! It sets in 10 min at 350
The bake time will depend on what type of pie you make. If you are baking an empty crust it will bake much more quickly than if it is filled with fruit. Follow the baking time for whichever recipe you are using for the filling.
My sourdough starter is different. It is a potato flake starter and is more liquid than yours. How would I adapt this recipe to use it? I hate to throw it away if it can be used for other recipes!
Figure out how much water is in 8 oz of starter and adjust accordingly. My 8 oz of starter includes 4 oz of water. So if your starter would have 6 oz of water maybe use a bit less than the recipe.
Thank you! I just poured the starter in until I got to the desired texture. The crust was wonderful on my Tomato Tart!!
Perfect.
Hi… Do I need to half
bake the pastry first before putting in the fillings
Depends on the filling. If it’s something that need to cook (like a fruit filling) you can put it into the unbaked crust. If the filling is already cooked (like chicken stew for chicken pot pie) you can prebake the bottom crust.
Sounds amazing & I would love to make a apple pie or a fruit pie of some kind with this recipe, however I have a important question, surprised nobody asked already , is the starter supposed to be fed or unfed and if Fed how long prior to using it to mix this crust up?
Thanks
When the ingredient says “sourdough discard” that means it a starter that hasn’t been fed. “Discard” means the portion of the starter that you would throw away when you need to feed the starter.
Do you warm the dough after it has been refrigerated for hours? My first try was rested in the fridge overnight for 12 hours and came out like a brick. Second try, I refrigerated for 1 hour, still a brick, warmed it another hour. Still kind of a brick.
I’ll often chop the dough into chunks and smush it up a bit to soften enough to roll. Just be careful not to let the butter melt or you’ll loose the flakes. Also, if you form it into a not too thick disc before refrigerating it’s a little easier to work with than if it’s a thick brick.
I am so excited to try this recipe for tomorrow, and just wanted to suggest for others who might be reading comments and thinking about this for the holidays: grate the pie crust into the pie pan. Once it’s all grated, use your fingers to press it into shape in the pan. The technique has been heralded as the best way to keep the flakiness of the pie crust (as seen in New York Times Cooking), and is perfect for this, as it’s meant for cold dough. If you’re doing a two-crust pie, leave the other crust out while you grate the first into the pan, and it should be soft enough to roll out by the time you’ve finished pressing the grated crust into the pan. I’m making this this afternoon and putting into the fridge for tomorrow (I’ll let it sit for an hour out and refrigerate for 14 hours), since my sister (like the reader above) is sensitive to gluten but does very well with sourdough/fermented wheat. Thank you so much for this recipe!
I haven’t tried the grating technique. My only concern would be a using your hands to press the bits into the plate might warm the dough up too much. Just be careful not to over handle the dough to the point the fat melts out.
Would this crust be good for pot pies?
Absolutely! I made a chicken pot a pie a couple of weeks ago with a double sourdough crust.
Great recipe! I used it for twee rhubarb frangipane galettes en they turned out very tasty. The dough was really flaky and good. Thanks!
Twee rhubarb galettes! They sound perfect.
Making chicken pot pie for my dinner today.. Would like to know if I need to bake the bottom layer for 5 mins first
Because the filling is already cooked, I do blind bake the bottom layer when I make chicken pot pie. You can see photos in my Heirloom Tomato Pie post how to blind bake a pie crust.
I don’t have cake flour. will all AP work?
Yes. You can use all AP flour.
If you don’t use the cake flour and shortening, how much flour and butter should you use?
If you don’t use shortening just use the same amount of butter in place of it. You can replace the 2/3 cup of cake flour with 1/2 cup of all purpose flour plus a tablespoon + a teaspoon of corn starch. If you don’t have corn starch just go ahead and use all purpose flour in place of the cake flour.
I’d love to try sourdough pie crust, except I do not like to use shortening. What effect would using all butter or some oil have on the recipe?
All butter would work just fine.
Could you make this pie crust dough ahead of time and freeze it?
Yes.
Thank you Eileen Gray… Used your recipe… I did change the amount of the shortening… Less shortening n more butter… The pastry was good…would like to know how long can I keep the left over pastry in the fridge.