Salt, baking powder and baking soda in cake batter
Cake recipes have just a small amount of salt, baking powder and/or baking soda. But salt and leavening agents have a big impact on the taste and texture of a cake.
In the first Cake Batter class we started the process of taking apart and examining the original pound cake recipe which uses only flour, eggs, sugar and butter in equal parts.
Neither salt nor leaveners are a part of the original pound cake formula. I think that cakes baked from the original recipe are a little dense and taste a bit flat.
Now we’ll learn about two additional ingredients in cake batter; salt & leavening agents.
To learn general information about the types of salt and how they work in baking, please visit the Baking Ingredients – Salt post. This class will specifically cover how salt works in cake batter.
What is a leavening agent?
A Leavening agent, or leavener, is a term for an ingredient that makes dough or batter rise.
How salt, baking powder & baking soda work in cake batter:
Now we’ll explore how the addition of salt and chemical leaveners can improve the original pound cake. These two ingredients are used in very small measure, but have a major impact on both the flavor and the texture of the cake.
I baked 9 pound cakes to test the effects of salt and baking powder, with wildly varying results.
What Salt does in Cake Batter:
A ½ teaspoon less or more of salt may not make much difference in a pot of soup, but it can make a great deal of difference in cake batter. My testing proved that, for our pound cake recipe, a little salt goes a long way.
Salt is not only a flavor enhancer. Salt also affects the tenderness of a baked good.
Salt molecules form strong bonds with flour proteins, causing the gluten molecules to become less mobile, which, in turn, makes the batter tighter and more elastic. This is a desirable trait in a bread dough, but is definitely not desirable in a cake batter.
I baked several cakes to test how salt changes the pound cake’s flavor and texture. All the cakes were made with room temperature ingredients and were baked in identical 9×5 loaf pans at 325°F in a convection oven.
Testing varying amounts of salt in pound cake
- As a control, I first baked a pound cake using only the four original ingredients and the reverse creaming method. Consistent with previous tests, the cake was fairly dense with a soft tender crumb and a slightly flat taste.
- For the next test I added a ½ teaspoon of table salt to the batter. The difference between the first and second cakes was really surprising.
- The cake with the added salt baked up higher due to the stronger gluten in the batter, and had a noticeably more chewy bite. The flavor was better than the first cake, less flat and more well-rounded, but the loss of tenderness was not good.
- I reduced the amount of salt to ¼ teaspoon for the third test. I found that was just enough salt to improve the flavor, yet keep the tenderness of crumb.
Now that we have just the right amount of salt in the cake, we can move on to the leavening.
About Baking Powder in Cake Batter
Please visit the Baking Ingredients – Chemical Leaveners page to learn all about the science of baking soda and baking powder. This class will discuss the specific effects that baking powder has on pound cake batter.
Based on the rule that 1 teaspoon of baking powder creates enough lift for each cup of flour in the batter, the correct amount of baking powder for our pound cake recipe should be about 1 ¾ teaspoons baking powder.
Testing varying amounts of baking powder in pound cake
- To test the ideal amount of leavening for our pound cake I baked 3 successive cakes, using 1 teaspoon, 2 teaspoons and 3 teaspoons of baking powder.
- The difference between the three cakes was quite striking. The cake made with 1 teaspoon of baking powder was nicely domed with a slightly open crumb.
- The cake made with 2 teaspoons of baking powder had a lighter, more open crumb and started to flatten a bit at the top, but it was still acceptable.
- The cake made with 3 teaspoons of baking powder collapsed down the middle because the batter could not hold the excess carbon dioxide. The crumb on cake 3 was rough and spongy.
Of the three cakes, I preferred the one made with 1 teaspoon of baking powder. It had a little lightness from the leavener, but retained the traditional pound cake texture.
The same pound cake recipe made with none, 1 tsp, 2 tsp and 3 tsp baking powder (top to bottom)
The same pound cake recipe made with gradually more baking powder. Too much leavener caused the last cake to collapse.
How baking powder is mixed into cake batter matters
It may be hard to believe, but there is yet another factor to consider regarding chemical leavening. How you add the leavening to the batter will affect the texture of the cake crumb.
What causes tunnels and holes in cake?
Leavening that is not thoroughly and evenly distributed through the batter will result in a cake with an uneven crumb and scattered tunnels and holes. You may even get an unpleasant bite of raw baking powder.
Testing the best way to mix baking powder into cake batter
- For the final round of tests I mixed 1 teaspoon of baking powder into the batter in 3 different ways.
- For the first cake I sifted the baking powder with the flour and then mixed the sifted ingredients together on low speed for a full 20-30 seconds before adding the butter.
- For the second test I sifted, but did not take the time to premix the dry ingredients before adding the butter.
- For the third cake I did not sift or premix the dry ingredients.
Once again, the difference between the baked cakes was clearly visible even before tasting. The first cake had a nice even crumb, the second cake had a slightly rougher crumb with some holes and the third cake had a rough open crumb with tunnels and holes throughout the cake.
Sifting and pre-mixing the leavening is definitely worth the few extra seconds it takes.
Other cake batter classes:
Next up: Cake Batter Class #3 will explore The function of flour in cake batter.
- Learn about Reverse Creaming
- The function of eggs in cake batter
- The function of sugar in cake batter
- The function of fat in cake batter
- The Cake recipe formula
When we’re done experimenting with all the ingredients for this “cake batter” course, we’ll use all we’ve learned to create Pound Cake Perfection.
This was the most informative info I have seen in two solid nights of searching thank you
I have a recipe that calls for 1 tablespoon of baking powder. Flavorwise is very good, consistency it is a bit dense. If I add baking soda will it get more airy? Let’s say 1/2 tablespoon? 1? Please advise.
Half a tablespoon is 1 1/2 teaspoons. You need just 1/4 tsp of baking soda to lift a cup of flour. So that would be way too much baking soda unless you’re making a huge recipe. Does your recipe have an acidic ingredient? A recipe could end up dense for reasons other than needing more leavening. In fact, too much leavening could cause the item to over-rise and collapse which could make it dense. It would be impossible to say why our item is dense without reviewing the entire recipe and process.
I’m curious of the ratio of flour to baking powder, but I’m not finding anything about how much flour went into the pound cake recipe. Was it one cup? I keep reading things where it says 1 cup flour to 1 tsp baking powder.
If you are asking about my Pound Cake Recipe there is 8 oz (1 3/4 cups) of cake flour in the recipe. As a general rule, 1 tsp of baking powder will lift 1 cup of flour in a recipe. But that is just a general guideline. Where the “art” comes into recipe development is adjusting the general rule to fit the exact result you are looking for. For example, in my pound cake recipe I settled on using 1 tsp of baking powder for 1 3/4 cups of flour to get just enough lift to lighten the crumb, but still keeping the iconic tight and even crumb of a classic pound cake.
BRILLIANT!
Yes, brilliant! I absolutely loved these series of articles. I’m kind of a nervous anyway, but learning how each individual ingredients effects the out come of cake is fascinating! This was very enlightening.
THANK YOU SO MUCH!
I am not clear on usage of salt in cake.
If i am making a cake with 1 cup or 1.5 cups or 2 cups of APF then the the salt qty of 1/4 tsp remains same
Or this has to be increased with increasing qty of flour
First of all, I personally would not make a cake with all purpose flour. Read through the Flour in cake batter post to get more information about the different flours. Regarding the amount of salt in the cake based on the amount of flour, I don’t have a set formula. The point of the post is to show how salt does make a difference in the batter beyond just flavor. I found that using 1/4 tsp salt for 1 3/4 cups of cake flour gave me the exact flavor and texture I wanted. If you are creating a cake recipe from scratch you can start from there. If you’re following a recipe but you’re not happy with the outcome the amount of salt is one thing to look at. If you find the cake too chewy and notice that the amount of salt seems high try reducing the total amount of salt to see if that helps. You can also read about The Cake Formula to see how all the ingredients in cake batter interact.
@Eileen Gray, I was taught if the recipe calls for APF use APF, and if the recipe calls for cake flour, use cake flour. Is that wrong?
That is correct. Use whichever flour is specified in the recipe you are using.
How many teaspoons of baking powder should be used for 5 cups of flour? Thanks.
You need about a teaspoon of baking powder for each cup of flour in a recipe. You can read more general information about leaveners in this post.
@Eileen Gray, if you add baking soda or salt, do you subtract the amount you need from the flour?
Ex. If I need 2 cups of flour, 1 tsp of baking soda, 1 tsp of salt, and 2 tsp of baking powder, would I formulate it with less flour to compensate for the salt and baking soda?
No. The amount of baking soda and salt would be determined by the amount of flour. Read through the post about the Science of baking powder and baking soda for details.
Awesome post, makes me want to make pound cakes. (:
Great. Try this recipe for Perfect Pound Cake.
I’m making a pound cake using a recipe I’d used as a base before. Just the classic recipe. But I wanted to tweak a few details, adding the salt and baking powder. So I did a search and found this amazing useful article! My only problem at this moment is I measured out everything by weight, especially because we’re dealing with Pound Cake. My Cake Flour measurement is off by 1/2 cup! To reach 225 grams I needed 2 1/4 cups. I’m really concerned about the balance of the recipe. Nothing I can do now except go by weight and hope I don’t mess it up. For the future, when you have this much variance, do you think weight is more important or volume? Thank you!
Measuring by weight is always more accurate because an oz is always an oz or a gram is always a gram. Measuring by volume will vary based on how you fill the cup. I use the “dip and sweep” method. That is where you dip the cup into the bin to fill it up and then sweep it level. If you use the method where you spoon the flour into the cup you’ll likely end up with less flour because as you spoon the flour you are fluffing it up and adding more air. So a cup of flour can weigh more or less based on how it’s filled. For my recipes you can assume a cup of cake flour weighs 4.5 oz or 126g.
Do you sift your flour?
Depends on the recipe. For a cake recipe, yes. For something like muffins or cookies, no. Unless it’s specific to sift the flour in the recipe you don’t need to.
This is the most thorough explanation on the use of leavening agents in baking that I have come across (including many cookbooks) and I greatly appreciate the time, patience and money you spent testing the cakes and publishing the results,
I have been struggling with a very old recipe for plum spice cake that keeps falling in the middle and your post may actually help me sleuth my way to a fix. Thank you!
That’s awesome, Karen! I spent months doing research for my series on cake ingredients and cake batter. I’m so glad it’s helpful. I have a private Facebook group for discussing recipes. Just ask to join and I’ll add you to the group. It’s a great place to troubleshoot recipes.
Hi,
Just went thru all the articles in this series. Very informative. Thanks for the research you have done on our behalf. I have a question…why cant self raising flour not substitute plain flour and baking powder in a recipe? I have many times subbed them for each other with varying results but nothing disastrous thankfully. Sometimes I see recipes with just 2 tsp of baking powder for 3 cups flour and makes me question if the recipe is corrected formulated.
Why do some cakes require just baking soda and no baking powder?
Hi Sheens, visit my “Chemical Leaveners” post to learn when and why each is used.
This article and recipe and the science of ingredients is the BEST I have ever had a chance to read. What a wonderful job <3
Why thank you! That’s so nice to hear. I worked really hard on the series.
Wow I have been looking for such research!!! What about 7 up cake can I still add the baking powder with the 7-up….my pound cakes have been good but a little heavy please advise…thanks!!!
Well, I haven’t worked with 7-up, but I imagine it’s just more liquid.
Thank you so much for your valuable advice and your time, hopefully the wedding cake will be a success. I am very interested in joining your Facebook group.
I have read this post with much interest as I am making my the wedding cake for my daughter. The cake is to be a lemon buttermilk, using fresh lemon juice. The recipes I have looked at use various amounts of either both baking powder /soda or just baking powder, it is very confusing.
The recipe uses 375gr of AP flour which is listed as 3 cups 1/2 teaspoon each of baking powder and soda, 240 mls buttermilk and 60 mls lemon. Another recipe uses identical ingredients apart from using only baking powder, 1 tblsp which I understand is 3 teasp in the US.
Will the tangy flavour of the buttermilk be lost using baking soda? Does that amount of acid require the use of some baking soda? Will b powder alone be enough to offset any ‘sourness’ from the acids while providing enough leavening for the flour.
Could you make any suggestions on which is the best combination to get a moist flavoursome light cake?
Thanks for any assistance you are able to provide.
Hi Jerrie, Did you also read the Baking Ingredients post about chemical leaveners? There is more information that might be helpful. Personally, when I want a lemon flavored cake I prefer to use lemon zest and lemon extract rather than lemon juice. Lemon juice is acidic, but lemon zest has much better lemon flavor because of the oil in the skin. Based on a recipe with 3 cups of flour, you would typically need about a tablespoon (3 teaspoons) of baking powder. A 1/4 teaspoon of baking soda has the same lift as 1 teaspoon of baking powder. A 1/4 teaspoon of baking soda will also neutralize the acid in 1 cup of buttermilk. Read the post in the link above to learn more about how much leavening to use to make your own judgement. But for a recipe with 3 cups of flour and about a cup of buttermilk I would use either a tablespoon of baking powder and no baking soda to keep a little of the buttermilk tang or 2 teaspoons of baking powder and a 1/4 teaspoon of baking soda to neutralize the acid in the buttermilk. If you add the lemon juice you could use 1 teaspoon of baking powder and 1/2 teaspoon of baking soda.
Thanks very much for your advice. Could you please indulge me with more of your time and knowledge, it was reading the linked post that prompted my query. Other posts have intimated, or at least I interpreted as meaning, if an acid is used then, baking soda is needed, whereas now my understanding is, if baking soda is used then acid needs to be used also, is that the correct way round? If baking powder alone can be used to leaven when acid is included, it appears the soda is not required for leavening. I understand that if included the b soda does leaven but will also neutralize the acids. Does this mean it negates the flavour of and tenderising effects of the buttermilk and lemon juice? What is the benefit of using baking soda, is there a level of aciditic ingredients at which baking soda should be used either alone, or in conjunction with baking powder, depending on the amount of flour?
Thanks
. Yes, this is correct. If you use baking soda without an acid the batter will be too alkaline and will have a soapy taste. I have made recipes using an acidic ingredient and no baking soda (just baking powder) with good results. You still get the benefits of the acid as far as tenderizing and flavor whether you use soda or powder for leavening. The main takeaway is that baking soda needs an acid to react with to produce carbon dioxide for leavening. Why would you ever use baking soda then? Well, acidic batters/doughs don’t brown as well so using baking soda with an acidic ingredient does improve the browning. Generally, for cakes I don’t want too much browning anyway, but for cookies I do. Jerrie-if you like these kinds of questions/answers I suggest you ask to join my Baking Sense Recipe Workshop group on Facebook. This is exactly the kind of thing we like to discuss. Just ask to join and I’ll add you to the group.
Love this post!! I just recently made a yellow cupcake recipe that turned out with the texture of corn bread, despite being careful not to overmix. After reading this, I know I didn’t distribute the leavener in the dry ingredients enough! Also, the recipe called for 1/8tsp of baking soda to offset a scant 2 tsp of buttermilk… From this post and the baking ingredient class, it seems that’s way too much. Could I just omit it all together and adjust the baking powder to do the lifting of the flour? About 1/2 tsp for 1/2 cup right?
Thanks, Sarah. I’m so glad the post is helpful. Yes, if the only acidic ingredient in the batter is 2 tsp of buttermilk I would just use baking powder. A 1/2 tsp of baking powder for a 1/2 cup of flour is a good amount. If you are a member of Facebook, I have a private Facebook group where we discuss questions exactly like this one. It’s called Baking Sense-Recipe Workshop. If you join the group you can post the recipe you’re working with and we can try and troubleshoot it for you. Let me know how the changes work.
Thank you so much, I will!
So for my pound cakes they typically ca for 3 c of flour, 3c sugar, etc 1tsp baking powder and salt. But dont rise alot. Should it be 1tsp baking powder per cup? How much salt per baking powder.
Hi Keosha. It’s hard to be exact without seeing the entire recipe, but I would say that you need a little more baking powder for a batter with 3 cups of flour. I would try using 2-3 tsp of baking powder and see how that works for you. As far as the salt, I like to use just enough to enhance the flavor of the cake, but not so much that it affects the texture. For 3 cups of flour I would try about 1/2 tsp salt.
This is pound cake art at its best! Your pictures were also well taken such that you can see the fine details.
Thanks! Photography is a work in progress for me.
Eileen, I love this series! It’s obvious you spent a lot of time on this and I truly appreciated that. I love learning about things like this, I always have those questions in the back of my mind, why you use certain ingredients and how much of them. Thank you for spending the time! And I do love a good pound cake 🙂
Thanks, Trang. It was a lot of work, but I’m weird and think research is fun!